Turning the Page: A book review of Thirty Six Fighting Holes by TJ Atwell

Photo courtesy of USMCCCA member and retired Master Sgt. Lukas “TJ” Atwell.
As members of the U.S. Marine Corps Combat Correspondents Association, we understand the power of a well-told story. Whether documenting history, capturing moments of courage or preserving the experiences of those who serve, storytelling matters.
In that tradition, Thirty-Six Fighting Holes: Confessions of a Marine Recruiter by Nathan Weidman offers readers an engaging look at the 8411 military occupational speciality, providing both insight and perspective that should resonate with PANCOs, MPARs, MACs and anyone interested in the human experience behind the story.
But don't take it from me, your executive director. Check out the book review below written by USMCCCA Member and retired Master Sgt. Lukas “TJ” Atwell.
This summer, the sight of one of my favorite Marine Corps recruiting posters stopped me while scrolling social media. It was on the cover of Thirty-Six Fighting Holes: Confessions of a Marine Corps Recruiter. The author was Nathan K. Weidman. “No way,” I said. I looked him up, and sure enough, it was my sergeant from 2002 and 2003, when I was an ammunition technician.
He was one of the first NCOs who really connected with me on a personal level. We had long since lost touch, but I had to know more. I preordered the book to show my support and reached out to congratulate him. He offered me an advance reader copy, which I accepted.
I was a little worried that “confessions” in the subtitle meant a collection of recruiting-duty debauchery. I’m glad I didn’t let that stop me.
Instead, what I found was a familiar voice. It wasn’t simply Weidman’s voice, which I hadn’t heard in more than 20 years. It was the voice of Marines I think we all know. He captures the way we talk, our competitive spirit and the dark humor we share in the most stressful times.
He writes about the Marine Corps I recognize and can be proud of, with enough affection and humility to leave room for embarrassment and earned criticism.
Recruiting is a job many of us think we understand because we had a recruiter. Weidman takes us to the other side of the desk.
He takes readers through recruiters school and into a three-year assignment in southern Illinois. Marines arrive from other occupations to learn a job that bears little resemblance to the fighting organization they imagined joining, or even the one they’ve spent years serving in. His experience and confidence in uniform do little to save him from a teenager who won’t return his call or an applicant who changes their mind about going to boot camp.
On his first recruiting appointment, Weidman hears the applicant’s mother threaten to shoot him before he even enters the house. Once they’re seated, she asks about his experience:
“So, how long have you been in the Marine Corps?”
“Seven years, ma’am, but I’m new to recruiting duty.”
“How new? And call me Tammy, by the way.”
I smiled. “Okay, I will. This is my first month on the job. Jacob is actually the first appointment I’ve ever had.”
“Really!” she said, appearing genuinely surprised. “And how’s everything been going for you?”
“Well, so far, one hundred percent of the parents I’ve met have threatened to shoot me.”
The recruiters have to smile, explain and persuade, often while concealing how much pressure they are under and how much they need this to work out. Being let in on what Weidman is actually thinking makes those encounters much funnier for us than they probably were for him.
I served as a marketing and public affairs representative at a Marine Corps recruiting station. I wasn’t a recruiter, but I knew the setting and the pressure surrounding them every month. Reading this book, I felt like I was back at the recruiting station, with the considerable advantage of being able to put it down. Instead, I kept wanting to know what happened next.
We’re in the moment with Weidman, working things out as he does. He isn’t always a reliable judge of what’s happening around him. We feel his frustration, follow him into mistakes and see what happens when he lets people down. At home, his wife, Erica, has to live with the demands of recruiting duty. Weidman doesn’t shy away from the effects of the job on his family.
Readers should expect profanity, sexual material and some uncomfortable behavior. They should also expect a funny, compelling account of a duty whose demands reach well beyond the recruiting office and into the daily lives and even dreams of the people involved. Former recruiters and Marines who supported them will find much to recognize. Sales professionals, civilian recruiters and anyone working under thankless and neverending performance goals may recognize the feeling of being a success one month and starting at zero the next.
I would recommend Thirty-Six Fighting Holes to those readers especially, but I think it’s a great way to peek behind the curtain for anyone interested in the Marine Corps, but not another war novel. Weidman makes an unfamiliar job understandable and had me laughing out along the read.
Disclosure: Weidman was my sergeant early in my Marine Corps career. I preordered the book and received an advance copy from him.


